What makes a High-Performing Website?

Your website could be an absolute work of art.

Beautiful photography. Slick animations.Typography that would make a designer weak at the knees.

But if nobody can find it, visitors can’t work out what you do and your contact form is gathering dust, there’s a bit of a problem.

Because it’s all well and good having a website you’re proud to show off. But is it actually getting you anywhere?

A high-performing website needs to attract the right people, make their lives easier and give them a reason to choose your business.

So, what does that actually involve?

What is a high-performing website?

A high-performing website isn’t just one that gets compliments.

It’s one people can find, understand and actually use without wanting to throw their laptop out the window.

It should load quickly, look the part and help your business get somewhere.

1. Make it painfully obvious what you do

Some websites are brilliant at using lots of words without actually telling you anything.

“We empower innovation through transformative solutions.”

Wonderful.

But what do you sell?

When someone arrives on your homepage, they shouldn’t have to spend five minutes figuring out what your business actually does.

Make it obvious who you help, what you offer and why they should stick around.

Try the 30-second test.

Show someone your homepage and ask three questions:

  • What does this business do?
  • Who is it for?
  • Why might someone choose them?

If they’re still scratching their head, your messaging could probably do with some attention.

A clear brand voice helps too. People should understand your business without needing a dictionary of corporate nonsense.

2. Make finding things ridiculously easy

Nobody visits your website hoping for a challenge.

They’re looking for something. Your job is to help them find it without sending them on an unexpected tour of seventeen unrelated pages.

That’s where user experience (UX) design comes in.

Good UX means organising information around what visitors actually need.

Think clear navigation, sensible page structures, useful internal links and obvious next steps.

For a consultancy, that might mean making specialist services and case studies easier to find.

For an online retailer, it could mean helping customers filter products and get through checkout without losing the will to live.

The best navigation is often the kind nobody notices.

Because everything just works.

3. Don’t make people wait around

We’ve all clicked on a website and wondered whether it’s actually loading or just having a little think about it.

Website speed and stability matter, both for users and for SEO.

Google’s Core Web Vitals measure three important aspects of page experience:

  • Largest Contentful Paint (LCP): How quickly the main content appears. Aim for 2.5 seconds or less.
  • Interaction to Next Paint (INP): How quickly the page responds to interactions. Aim for 200 milliseconds or less.
  • Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS): How much the layout unexpectedly moves. Aim for 0.1 or less.

These are Google’s good thresholds, assessed at the 75th percentile of page visits.

You can check performance using Google’s PageSpeed Insights.

And before you start deleting every image on your website, remember that great design and fast performance aren’t mutually exclusive.

Optimised images, efficient code and sensible use of animation can make a big difference.

It’s something we’ve explored further in our guide to sustainable website design.

4. Make mobile visitors feel welcome

Ever opened a website on your phone and found yourself zooming in, scrolling sideways and trying to click a button approximately the size of a grain of rice?

Not ideal.

A high-performing website should work just as well on a phone as it does on a desktop.

That means readable text, properly sized buttons, sensible spacing and navigation that’s easy to use with your thumb.

But responsive design is only the beginning.

Think about what mobile visitors are actually trying to do.

Someone looking for your opening hours probably doesn’t want to scroll past an enormous video before finding them.

And someone trying to make a purchase shouldn’t need three hands to complete checkout.

Design for how people actually use your website, not just how lovely it looks on a designer’s enormous monitor.

5. Give Google something worth finding

The world’s most beautiful website isn’t very useful if your customers can’t find it.

That’s where search engine optimisation comes in.

A well-performing website needs strong technical foundations, clear page structures and content that answers what people are searching for.

That means thinking about SEO from the beginning.

Not remembering it two days before launch and asking whether someone can “just add some keywords”.

Gone are the days when SEO was just about squeezing your favourite keyword into every available corner of your website.

Thankfully.

Now it’s about understanding what people want to know and giving them proper answers.

And with AI-powered search becoming another way people discover businesses, clear content and genuine expertise matter more than ever.

Our approach to SEO and organic marketing focuses on attracting the right visitors, rather than chasing traffic for the sake of it.

6. Give people a reason to trust you

Imagine finding a business that looks promising.

You like the website. The services sound right.

But there’s no evidence of previous work, no customer reviews and barely any information about the people behind it.

Would you hand over £20,000?

Probably not without asking a few questions.

Your website needs to help people feel confident about choosing you.

That might mean showing real projects, introducing your team, explaining your process or sharing testimonials that say something more useful than “Great service, highly recommend”.

And don’t hide your best work three clicks away.

For businesses with longer buying cycles, a good case study can be considerably more convincing than another paragraph explaining how passionate everyone is.

7. Make it easy to take the next step

Getting someone onto your website is only half the job.

What happens next?

Can visitors find your contact details? Is the enquiry form unnecessarily complicated? Do your calls to action actually tell people what they’re going to get?

A button saying “Submit” is technically doing its job.

But “Book a consultation” gives people a better idea of what happens next.

Think about the action you want someone to take on each page, then make that step clear and relevant.

We’ve covered more practical ideas in our guide to increasing website conversions.

Sometimes a few small improvements can make a bigger difference than redesigning the entire website.

8. Keep measuring, testing and improving

Website launched. Everyone’s happy. Time to put your feet up?

Not quite.

Getting it live is one thing. Making sure it’s actually working for your business is another.

It’s the beginning of finding out how well everything actually works.

Use Google Search Console to understand how people discover your website and Google Analytics 4 to see what happens once they arrive.

Our GA4 guide explains how to get started.

Look at which pages attract relevant visitors, where people drop off and whether they’re completing important actions.

Then investigate.

Is the problem your traffic? Your messaging? Your navigation? Or perhaps a contact form that’s quietly stopped working?

Don’t go throwing your entire website in the bin just yet. You might only need to fix a few things that are making life difficult for your visitors.

What a high-performing website looks like in practice

You know when a business is genuinely good at what it does, but you’d never quite guess it from the website?

That’s where Cyan Solutions needed a little help.

We made the navigation less of a treasure hunt, the messaging clearer and the enquiry process considerably easier.

Throw in some genuine team photography, proper SEO foundations and CRM integration, and you’ve got a website with a bit more purpose.

And it worked.

Within 90 days, traffic was up 80% and contact form submissions had increased by 158% year on year.

Much better than simply giving everything a fresh coat of paint.

Have a look at our work with Cyan.

How do you know if your website is performing well?

A good starting point is to look at five things:

What to checkWhat it tells you
Relevant organic trafficWhether the right people are discovering you
Engagement and user journeysWhether visitors are finding useful information
Enquiries or purchasesWhether the website supports your business goals
Core Web VitalsWhether your website loads and responds smoothly
Lead qualityWhether you’re attracting the customers you actually want

Don’t obsess over one number.

A website with 500 visitors and 20 valuable enquiries might be doing a much better job than one attracting 10,000 people who have absolutely no interest in your services.

Context matters.

High-performing website FAQs

Does website design affect conversion rates?

Yes. Clear navigation, trustworthy content, accessible layouts and relevant calls to action can make it easier for visitors to take the next step. The impact of individual changes should be measured rather than assumed.

Does website speed affect SEO?

Yes. Google uses Core Web Vitals as part of its ranking systems, although fast loading alone won’t guarantee better rankings. Useful, relevant content remains essential.

How often should you update your website?

There’s no universal timetable. Review performance regularly and update your content, design or functionality when your business or customers’ needs change.

And if your website no longer reflects the business you’ve become, it might be worth exploring whether it’s time for a redesign.

Your website should be doing more than looking pretty

We love a beautiful website. Obviously.

But we’re much more interested in what it actually achieves.

At Giant Peach, we bring together strategy, UX, design, development and marketing to create websites that help businesses grow.

Your website could have the most beautiful shop window on the high street.

But if nobody’s coming through the door, there’s probably something worth looking at.

Fancy turning a few more window shoppers into customers?

Let’s get your website pulling its weight.

More Updates Delivered!

"*" indicates required fields

Read this next

Read this next