What Makes a Good Logo? 6 Things Every Business Should Know

Some logos stick in your head for years. Others look like someone discovered Canva over their lunch break and got a little carried away.

And then there are the beautiful ones. Lovely typography, clever little details, the sort of design that gets everyone nodding enthusiastically in a presentation. But whether they’re actually doing anything useful for the business is another question entirely.

Because a good logo needs to earn its keep.

It should reflect what your business is all about, give people something recognisable to remember and work wherever you need to put it. From the tiniest social media icon to the side of a building.

And ideally, it shouldn’t need a complete rethink every time the design world develops a new obsession.

So, what separates a genuinely good logo from one that simply looks the part?

What makes a good logo?

The best logos have a few things in common. They’re distinctive, memorable, flexible enough to work just about anywhere and, most importantly, they feel right for the business behind them.

Sounds straightforward enough when you put it like that. But bringing all those ingredients together takes a fair bit more thought than choosing a nice font and calling it a day.

Let’s take a look at six principles that make all the difference.

1. Be distinctive, not just attractive

Imagine putting your logo next to ten of your closest competitors.

Would it catch your eye? Or would you find yourself staring at eleven remarkably similar combinations of colours, fonts and symbols?

It’s an easy trap to fall into. Everyone’s looking at the same competitors, keeping an eye on the same trends and gathering inspiration from the same corners of Pinterest. Before long, half the industry looks like it went shopping for a brand identity together.

Technology companies seem particularly fond of blue geometric shapes, while luxury brands have developed a rather serious obsession with minimalist typography.

All very tasteful. Just a shame nobody can tell who’s who.

A good logo should have a personality of its own. That doesn’t mean being deliberately outrageous or giving your accountancy firm a fluorescent pink identity for the fun of it.

It’s about understanding what people expect from your industry, then working out where there’s room to do something different.

Because a logo can look absolutely beautiful and still give people no reason to remember it.

2. Keep it simple (but not painfully boring)

Designers love banging on about simplicity. And to be fair, they’ve got a point.

A logo needs to work everywhere from a whopping great billboard to that tiny little icon sitting in your browser tab. Fill it with too many intricate details and things start getting messy pretty quickly.

But minimalism has a habit of getting a little carried away.

One minute you’re tidying up a few unnecessary bits. The next, you’ve stripped away all the personality and ended up with something that could belong to half the businesses on the high street.

We’ve seen plenty of brands head down that road, swapping distinctive lettering and recognisable symbols for increasingly similar minimalist identities.

Sometimes it’s a brilliant move. Other times, you wonder whether anyone thought to ask what made the original logo special.

Good designers know what deserves to stay and what can happily go. And that’s often where the real skill lies.

A little logo design thinking from Giant Peach

When we worked on the brand identity for Farmer’s Yarn, a festival celebrating British wool, we weren’t exactly going for your typical countryside branding.

You know the sort. A sheep, a field, a nice shade of green. Job done.

Instead, we wanted something that celebrated the festival’s agricultural roots while giving it a much more contemporary personality.

Our designers explored three different creative directions, combining bold, brutalist-inspired typography with organic textures and modern colour gradients. The result was an identity that felt both handcrafted and refreshingly modern.

And it wasn’t just about looking good on a festival poster. The identity also needed to work as an accreditation mark for British wool, so flexibility was built into the design from the start.

It’s a lovely example of why good logo design isn’t about following the obvious conventions of an industry.

Sometimes, the best way to represent what makes a business special is to do something its competitors wouldn’t dream of.

3. Make sure your logo actually works in the real world

Picture the scene. Your designer reveals your new logo, beautifully positioned against a tasteful background, with every little detail looking absolutely perfect.

Everyone loves it. Champagne all round.

Then someone tries to use it as a tiny social media icon and half the design disappears.

Not ideal.

The trouble is, businesses often judge logos by how impressive they look in a presentation, rather than how well they’ll actually work once they’re let loose in the wild.

Your logo could end up on:

  • Your website and mobile navigation
  • Social media profiles and favicons
  • Packaging, signage and merchandise
  • Printed materials and presentations
  • Digital advertising and video content

A well-developed brand identity might include a primary logo, a secondary arrangement, a simplified symbol and versions that work against different backgrounds.

And ideally, your designer should provide scalable vector files, so your logo can go from business card to billboard without turning into a pixelated disaster.

Because your logo should still look the business, even when it’s squeezed into the tiniest corner of the internet.

4. Your logo doesn’t need to explain everything you do

There’s a temptation when designing a logo to cram absolutely everything your business does into one little symbol.

Construction company? Stick a building in it. Coffee shop? Better find a coffee bean. Digital agency? Perhaps a tiny computer mouse, just in case anyone’s confused.

But your logo doesn’t need to explain your entire business in one go.

Look at Apple. There’s nothing about that little bitten apple that screams smartphones, laptops or technology. Yet you’d struggle to find many people who don’t recognise it.

Of course, Apple’s had a few years and a rather healthy marketing budget to get there. But the thinking applies to businesses of all shapes and sizes.

A logo should give people something distinctive to recognise and associate with your business. It doesn’t need to explain everything you sell.

That’s what the rest of your brand identity is for. Your colours, typography, photography, messaging and website all have a part to play in telling your story.

Expecting one tiny symbol to do the lot is asking a bit much, don’t you think?

5. Design for the business you’re becoming

There’s a reason some logos have barely changed in decades, while others seem to get a makeover every few years.

Design trends have a lot to do with it. What looks brilliant today might feel rather tired five years down the line, particularly if the whole identity was built around whatever happened to be fashionable at the time.

That’s not to say brands should never change. Far from it. A business might have grown into new markets, developed a completely different offering or outgrown the identity it started with.

But before getting carried away with a redesign, it’s worth asking what’s actually changed.

Has the business moved on, or has someone simply got bored of the logo?

The answer matters. Sometimes a considered brand refresh is all that’s needed. Other times, the positioning and wider identity need a proper rethink.

The clever little details hiding in the world’s most iconic logos

Some of the world’s most recognisable logos have been hiding clever little design details right under our noses for years.

And while they’re fun to spot, there’s usually a lot more going on than designers simply showing off.

Here are three of our favourites, and why they’re actually rather brilliant.

  • FedEx: The arrow hiding in plain sight. Look between the E and the X in the FedEx logo. See that little arrow? Once you spot it, you’ll never look at a delivery van quite the same way again. It’s a brilliant example of negative space, where the empty space around design elements becomes part of the design itself. The clever part is that the arrow isn’t an additional graphic. It’s formed by the carefully considered relationship between two letterforms, subtly suggesting speed, direction and movement.

  • Toblerone: A little bear with a big backstory. Remember the mountain on Toblerone’s classic packaging? Look closely and you’ll find a bear hidden within the mountain’s shape. It’s a nod to Bern, the Swiss city where Toblerone originated, which happens to have a famous association with bears. Beyond being a clever visual trick, it’s an example of how symbolism can communicate brand heritage without spelling everything out. Rather than squeezing a load of historical references into the design, the bear adds another layer of meaning for people to discover.

  • Amazon: One little arrow, two big ideas. You’ve probably noticed the orange smile underneath Amazon’s name. But have you ever looked at where it starts and finishes? The arrow connects the A to the Z, referencing the enormous range of products the business sells. And its upward curve creates a smile, suggesting customer satisfaction. Two messages, one incredibly simple graphic. And through years of consistent use, the curved smile has become a recognisable brand asset in its own right, appearing across Amazon’s packaging and customer touchpoints.

So, what do all three have in common?

You’ll notice none of these logos is desperately trying to tell you everything about the business.

There’s no illustrated list of services, no complicated collection of symbols and certainly no attempt to squeeze an entire brand strategy into a few square centimetres.

Just a distinctive visual idea, thoughtfully brought to life.

And while the clever design deserves plenty of credit, it hasn’t achieved all that recognition on its own.

Years of consistent marketing, branding and customer experiences have helped make these logos familiar to millions.

That’s the difference between designing a clever logo and building a memorable brand.

6. Test whether it works, not just whether people like it

This is where things get interesting.

You’ve got three logo concepts. Everyone has a favourite. Someone’s partner prefers the blue one. The finance director thinks the font looks expensive.

And suddenly, a strategic design decision has become a popularity contest.

But personal preference isn’t necessarily a good measure of logo effectiveness.

People will always have opinions about design. That doesn’t mean every opinion should carry equal weight.

Instead, test your logo against what it’s supposed to achieve.

The five-question logo test

  1. Is it distinctive? Does it look sufficiently different from competitors?
  2. Is it appropriate? Does it reflect the positioning and personality of your business?
  3. Is it recognisable? Could someone identify it after seeing it briefly?
  4. Is it versatile? Does it remain legible and effective at different sizes and across different applications?
  5. Is it built to last? Will it still feel relevant as your business develops?

Try viewing your logo alongside competitors. Test it at the smallest size it’ll realistically appear. See how it works in one colour. Put it on an actual website mock-up rather than judging it in isolation.

For more meaningful feedback, show it to people who represent your target audience and ask what kind of business they think it belongs to, rather than simply whether they like it.

And don’t expect a completely new logo to achieve instant recognition. Familiarity takes time, consistent use and good marketing.

A logo can be brilliantly designed and still mean very little to someone encountering it for the first time.

That’s perfectly normal.

So, does your business need a better logo?

Maybe. But before you go throwing your existing logo in the bin, it’s worth having a proper look at why you’re thinking about changing it.

Has it become awkward to use? Is it looking a little too much like the competition? Or has your business grown into something your original branding no longer represents?

Sometimes the logo is the problem. Other times, it’s simply the most obvious place to point the finger.

At Giant Peach, we like to get under the skin of a business before we start dreaming up new designs. We’ll have a good nose around your positioning, branding, website and marketing to understand what’s working, what’s not and where things could be better.

Because a brilliant brand identity needs more than a lovely logo. It needs some proper thinking behind it, and everything around it needs to be pulling in the same direction.

Think your branding might need a little love? Come and have a chat. We’ll work out where to start.

More Updates Delivered!

"*" indicates required fields