How to Create Customer Personas That Actually Help Your Business

Somewhere in a marketing department, there’s a customer persona called Marketing Manager Melanie. She’s 38, loves yoga, drinks oat milk flat whites and spends her weekends wandering around independent shops.

You know everything about her Sunday routine, but absolutely nothing about why she’d buy from you.

And that’s where customer personas can go a bit wrong. They’re supposed to help you understand what people need, what makes them tick and what’s stopping them from choosing your business.

Not give you enough material to write their dating profile.

So, how do you create customer personas that are actually useful?

What is a customer persona, and why does it matter?

Think of a customer persona as a little window into your audience’s world.

It’s a research-backed profile that helps you understand what customers care about, what they’re trying to achieve and what might be putting them off.

And when your whole team understands those things, making decisions about your website, messaging and marketing becomes a whole lot easier.

The interesting stuff isn’t necessarily how old someone is or where they live. It’s why they’re looking for a solution in the first place and what would convince them they’ve found the right one.

1. Start with research, not a very imaginative guessing game

One of the easiest ways to get customer personas wrong is to gather everyone around a table and start guessing.

Someone suggests your ideal customer is a 35-year-old marketing director, somebody else decides she probably loves yoga, and before you know it, you’ve invented a woman whose weekend plans are more detailed than your actual marketing strategy.

The trouble is, nobody’s asked a real customer what they want.

At Giant Peach, we prefer to start with a bit of proper detective work. Through brand strategy and audience profiling, we dig into customer behaviour, chat with stakeholders and have a good look at the competition to find out who’s buying, why they’re buying and what might be getting in their way.

You can start by looking at information your business already has:

  • Customer interviews: Ask recent customers what prompted their search, what alternatives they considered and what nearly stopped them choosing you.
  • Sales conversations: Find out which questions and objections keep cropping up before someone buys.
  • Website analytics and search data: Explore which services attract attention, what people search for and where visitors struggle or leave.
  • Reviews and support enquiries: Look for recurring frustrations, expectations and reasons customers appreciate your business.

Don’t forget about the people who decided not to buy. They might have some of the most useful things to tell you, even if they’re not quite as flattering as your five-star reviews.

And while Google Analytics can show you exactly where someone abandoned your website, it can’t tell you whether they were confused, unconvinced or simply got distracted by the dog. Sometimes you just need to ask.

2. Understand what customers are trying to achieve

Here’s a little trick that can completely change how you think about your customers.

Stop asking who they are for a moment and start asking what they’re trying to achieve. Someone looking for a new website probably hasn’t woken up with an overwhelming desire for better typography and a few fancy animations.

Their business might have outgrown its current website, enquiries could be drying up or they’re struggling to attract the bigger clients they know they’re capable of working with.

That’s the thinking behind Jobs to Be Done: understanding the real problem driving someone’s decision.

Because the website might be what they’re buying, but the business problem is what they’re actually paying you to solve.

What we learned from Go Ape

Take our work with Go Ape. On the surface, everyone’s turning up for a bit of adventure in the trees.

But dig a little deeper and the reasons people visit couldn’t be more different. Parents want to know their children will have a brilliant time, corporate organisers need to coordinate a small army of colleagues and adrenaline junkies are already wondering how high they can climb.

We visited locations, spoke with stakeholders and used customer empathy mapping to understand those different needs.

Then we brought that thinking into the website’s user journeys, wireframes and mobile-first design.

Because one website needs to make sense to all of them, without sending anyone on an obstacle course just to find the information they need.

3. Get to the bottom of what makes people buy

People don’t usually wake up one morning and decide to spend a sizeable chunk of money for the fun of it.

Something’s prompted them to start looking, they’ve got something they want to achieve and there’s probably a little voice in their head wondering whether they’re making the right decision.

We call these the trigger, the motivation and the hesitation.

Perhaps a marketing director is searching for a new agency because growth has slowed. They want better results, but they’re worried about explaining the investment to the board.

Understand that, and you can stop showing them another collection of pretty websites and start giving them the evidence, reassurance and commercial thinking they actually need.

4. Find out why someone might choose your competitor

Here’s a question businesses don’t ask nearly enough.

Why would someone choose your competitor instead of you?

Perhaps they’re cheaper, their website makes more sense or they’ve got a few cracking case studies that make them look like the safer bet. Maybe customers don’t even realise you offer what they’re looking for.

Awkward.

That’s why we love digging into the decisions that didn’t go your way. Find out what nearly put people off, what they struggled to understand and why somebody else won them over.

Sometimes the problem isn’t what you’re offering. It’s how customers perceive your business compared with everyone else competing for their attention.

It’s something we explore through our thinking on the Visibility Gap, where brilliant businesses aren’t always doing a brilliant job of showing the world what they’re capable of.

5. Build two or three customer personas that mean something

Now you’ve done the digging, it’s time to turn all those lovely insights into something your business can actually use.

But before you start inventing fifteen different customers, complete with names, hobbies and imaginary Labradors, keep things manageable.

For most businesses, two or three well-researched personas are a perfectly good starting point, provided they represent people with genuinely different needs.

Take a specialist B2B consultancy, for example.

PersonaWhat matters mostBiggest buying barrier
Marketing DirectorDemonstrating results and getting internal buy-inConcern about return on investment
Managing DirectorConfidence, expertise and a clear commercial benefitLimited time and uncertainty about delivery
Procurement LeadEvidence, compliance and confidence in the supplierRisk, cost justification and contractual requirements

Notice how nobody needs a favourite supermarket, a star sign or an imaginary dog called Biscuit.

We’re interested in what actually influences their decisions. And don’t get too hung up on job titles either.

Two people doing completely different jobs might share the same goals and concerns, while a single B2B purchase could involve five people with five very different priorities.

For each persona, focus on what they want to achieve, what’s making them hesitate and how they go about choosing a supplier.

Then comes the important bit: back it up with evidence. If customers keep mentioning the same frustration, make a note of it. If you’re guessing, admit it.

Because a useful persona should be built on what you’ve learned, not what everyone around the meeting table reckons sounds about right.

6. Put those personas to work across your website and marketing

A customer persona that lives in a PowerPoint presentation and never gets opened again isn’t doing anybody much good.

The real value comes when it starts influencing decisions.

Think about the customer journey

Imagine visiting a school website because you’re thinking about sending your child there, only to spend the next ten minutes rummaging through pages intended for existing parents and former pupils.

Not exactly the introduction you were hoping for.

That’s one of the challenges we explored while working with Port Regis, a prestigious Dorset prep school. We immersed ourselves in the school, spoke with staff, spent time with pupils and investigated how different audiences navigated the existing website.

Then we used those findings to streamline the content and create clearer routes for prospective families, current parents and alumni.

It’s the same thinking that should guide your marketing. Someone just getting to know you needs explanations and reassurance, while someone ready to buy would probably appreciate a contact page that doesn’t require a search party.

7. How do you know whether your customer personas are actually useful?

We have a favourite question when it comes to customer personas. What have you actually done differently because of them?

If the answer involves improving your website, clearing up confusing messaging or making it easier for customers to choose you, you’re on the right track.

If the answer is that you’ve created a very attractive PDF featuring a fictional man called Dave, perhaps there’s more work to do.

A useful persona should help you attract more relevant enquiries, answer objections and improve the experience people have with your business.

And if your research has uncovered problems with your website, it might be time to look at how you can improve website conversions by making things easier for the people using it.

Keep an eye on analytics, conversions and customer feedback to see whether those things are changing.

Just remember that marketing results rarely have one neat explanation, and the personas you created three years ago probably deserve another look.

Better customer understanding. Better business decisions.

There’s nothing wrong with giving your customer personas a name, a face and a bit of personality.

But knowing that Marketing Manager Melanie enjoys yoga isn’t going to help much when you’re trying to work out why she’s choosing your competitor.

What matters is knowing what your customers are trying to achieve, what’s standing in their way and how your business can help.

Understand those things and you’ve got something that can genuinely shape your strategy, website and marketing.

That’s why, at Giant Peach, we love getting under the skin of the businesses we work with and the people they’re trying to reach.

Through brand strategy, audience research and website design, we turn those insights into clearer messaging and digital experiences that make sense to real people.

Because the better you know your customers, the less guessing you have to do. Let’s have a chat about getting to know yours.